At the 2000 American Comedy Award, Levy was nominated for Funniest Supporting Actor in a Motion Picture although he didn't win. At the 2000 Blockbuster Entertainment Award he was nominated for Favorite Supporting Actor – Comedy, which he won. At the 2002 Canadian Comedy Awards he was nominated for Pretty Funny Male Performance for his role in American Pie 2 and won the award. He first appears in American Pie where he attempts to offer sexual advice including purchasing and giving his son Jim pornography after finding him masturbating with a tube sock. He later finds Jim humping a pie after being previously told that third base feels like 'warm apple pie'.
He later helps Jim cover the incident up and lies to his wife about the missing pie and where it has gone, telling her he ate it. He reappears in the second film of the series where he takes Jim to the hospital after Jim decides to turn on a porn film that Stifler rented, but accidentally uses superglue instead of lubricant to masturbate, permanently gluing his entire hand to his penis and boxer shorts. He then supports Jim after he learns that he won't be able to have sex for at least a whole week, the same amount of time before the party he is attending with Nadia, whom he plans on sleeping with, will be held. In the third installment Noah arrives at the restaurant Jim is at to give him the wedding ring he was going to use to propose to girlfriend Michelle. Jim tries to hide the fact that he is being fellated.
